News

Filter By:

Fix the Court Creates Its Own Disclosure Database for Circuit Judges, Finds More Posted Than Expected

Fix the Court has created a database of circuit judges’ 2021-2025 financial disclosure reports to visualize the judiciary’s successes and failures in complying with a 2022 law requiring every judge’s disclosure to be posted online by Thursday night.

Of the 272 circuit judges in active or senior status required to file, 237, or 87.1%, of their 2025 reports were in the database by last week’s so-called second posting deadline.

That means 35 circuit judges’ disclosures are still missing, with 10 of those coming from the Third Circuit alone. (We do not include the 20 inactive senior circuit judges nationwide, nor those confirmed in 2026, nor those who served fewer than 60 days in 2025 and were not required to file.)

Each year, the statutory filing deadline is May 15, and the first posting deadline is 90 days after that, or Aug. 13. But many judges — including at least a third of circuit judges — request a 90-day extension, meaning their filing deadline is Aug. 13 and the AO’s second posting deadline is Nov. 12.

Overall, there were 2,054 disclosures for calendar year 2025 in the database by the morning of Nov. 13 out of 2,200 judges required to file, or 93.4%. That’s a major improvement; this time last year, only about half of the 2024s were posted. It also marks a major ramp-up since the summer: as of Aug. 13, only 1,184, or 53.8%, of the 2025s were posted.

“Financial disclosures play an important role in maintaining public trust in our courts,” FTC’s Gabe Roth said. “They help judges think critically about their outside entanglements, and documenting them each year helps judges stay informed about their recusal obligations. They also act as a backstop for litigants and the public, as we can use them to check that judges aren’t ruling in cases in which they have a financial or personal interest. ”

“The numbers today are now the floor, and we expect the judiciary to be at least this diligent in fulfilling its statutory obligations to post the disclosures online in future years,” Roth added.

Since the database must include stock transaction reports, the work at the AO’s Committee on Financial Disclosure may increase in the short term once Congress passes a stock ban that includes the judiciary, as FTC is advocating for.

Reaching out:
Twenty-one circuit judges, listed here, have more than one missing disclosure for the years covered by the database. We reached out to each of them or to their circuit executive to ask about the holdup, and we will update that sheet as more answers become available.

So far, a D.C. Circuit judge had one of her missing disclosures posted after our outreach. Two others, one from the Seventh Circuit and one from the Ninth Circuit, thanked us for bringing this to their attention, with the Ninth Circuit judge saying she understood “that the AO has remedied the situation.” (It hasn’t.) One Third Circuit judge said his reports were filed by the extension — we believe all the missing reports were filed by the extension, and the delay is on the AO’s end — and that FTC should contact the AO to find them. The Federal Circuit’s PIO said it’s “currently coordinating with the AO on this item.”

Redactions:
Judges may request redaction of certain information in their disclosures if they believe the information might imperil their security. Typically, this is used to black out words like “husband,” “wife,” “spouse” or “child” in the area of a judge’s investments or the name of an extracurricular activity a judge participates in, like coaching or advising students.

Whatever the information, FTC maintains that the staff and judges on the Committee on Financial Disclosure, working with the U.S. Marshals, should not take six months to decide whether a redaction request is valid.

Even so, we hope that in the future judges requesting redactions file their reports closer to Jan. 1 than May 15 or Aug. 13. FTC is in good company; the chairman of the Financial Disclosure Committee made the same complaint in 1984.

Self-fulfilling:
It’s worth noting that as Congress drafted the Courthouse Ethics and Transparency Act in early 2022, the judiciary lobbied for an implementation period that would allow them three to five years to create an online disclosure database.

Thankfully, the law limited that work to six months, and a database went live in Nov. 2022. Unfortunately, it took the branch four years to get in the neighborhood of compliance.

Additional information:
The reason for today’s release is as follows:
— Statutory disclosure filing deadline for all judges: May 15
— Statutory posting deadline, i.e., 90 days after the first filing deadline: Aug. 13
— Second filing deadline if a judge is granted an extension: also Aug. 13
— Second posting deadline, i.e., 90 days after the first filing deadline, plus one day (Nov. 11 is Veterans’ Day): Nov. 12 at 11:59 p.m.

Fix the Court has not yet decided whether to create a disclosure database comprising district, magistrate and/or bankruptcy judges but will add new disclosures to our circuit court database as they become available.

Related News

Get the Latest
">email