News

Filter By:

Fix the Court to Fifth Circuit: Confirm Whether Complaint Against Judge Brown Exists

Fix the Court’s Gabe Roth today wrote to the circuit executive and clerk of the Fifth Circuit requesting that Chief Judge Elrod issue a release confirming the existence of a misconduct complaint against N.D. Texas Judge Ada Brown (right) if there is one.

In a highly unusual move, N.D. Texas Chief Judge O’Connor on Oct. 5 reassigned all of Judge Brown’s cases.

Since then, almost no information has come out about why that happened, though rumors of both misconduct and health issues have arisen.

If it’s the former, wrote Roth, the Fifth Circuit has a responsibility to reassure the public that the misconduct is being addressed.

The commentary to Rule 23 of the Judicial Conduct & Disability Rules states, “In extraordinary circumstances, a chief judge […] may disclose the existence of a proceeding under these Rules. The disclosure of such information in high-visibility or controversial cases is to reassure the public that the judiciary is capable of redressing judicial misconduct or disability.”

This would seem to be the type of “extraordinary circumstance” the Rules are referring to.

If it’s the latter (i.e., a health issue), the public deserves to know roughly how long Judge Brown’s medical leave is expected to last.

If the answer is “indefinite” and “please respect her privacy,” that’s fine, but when a life-tenured judge receives a salary while performing no work, the public should know some of the circumstances that led to that situation.

Related News

Get the Latest
">email